public

“Drummer” Weakest Link in Fan Footage of First Official Agoraphobic Nosebleed Show at MDF

Maryland Deathfest has proven itself to be the greatest North American extreme metal festival year after year, with a consistently stellar lineup complete with a multitude of exclusive performances from

9 years ago

Maryland Deathfest has proven itself to be the greatest North American extreme metal festival year after year, with a consistently stellar lineup complete with a multitude of exclusive performances from disbanded, foreign or typically non-touring acts. This year was no different, as Agoraphobic Nosebleed appeared onstage for their first ever live-performance, of which their is fan-footage available. However, despite the solid video quality and overall great performance, there is something missing – literally – from the band’s debut concert. Watch the videos and read more after the jump:

Self-Detonate

Hung From the Rising Sun

There is really nothing to critique the present members of ANb for: Scott Hull’s guitar work is as on point as it always is and all three of the band’s vocalists appear in full swing, particularly the throat-shredding Katherine Katz. Yet, while it is common knowledge that Hull programs all of the band’s drumming, this fact becomes apparent and a hindrance in this footage. Drummer-less bands like Godflesh can put on an enjoyable live performance due to both having an interesting backdrop and their simple percussion that often sounds like a drum machine anyway. Grindcore is an entirely different beast, however, one that has drumming that is much more interesting to watch. Hull does an excellent job – for the most part – of making ANb’s “drummer” sound organic on record, but the lack of a physical performance causes the live performance to seem unavoidably incomplete. Pair this with an excess of vocalists and various individuals standing in where the drummer and/or backdrop should be and the result is almost comparable to the stage at a hip-hop concert, something that can be fine in its own right but is not all that preferable for a show of this style. Granted, experiencing a live performance is much different from watching it; this observation may have been negligible to the Baltimore crowd. But if this performance were to be turned into a concert DVD, it does not seem that it would be worth purchasing.

-SM

Scott Murphy

Published 9 years ago