It’s been about a decade since I first laid ears upon Hungarian maverick(s) Thy Catafalque. In that time, I’ve scarcely asked myself: 'what is a “Catafalque”?'. This fomented a strange, dissonant assumption when I managed to convince myself the name was actually of Hungarian origin, betraying any linguistic instinct in the process. As it turns out, a catafalque is a raised platform used to afford a body or coffin a suitable level of elevation during funerary proceedings. Aside from being a particularly metal word, it also shares distinct qualities with the project that carries its moniker and provides a similarly specific, somewhat obscure and cathartic experience.
Thy Catafalque pertains to a journey supported by community, but eventually undertaken by one individual. That individual is either its audience, or its solitary creator and composer, the inimitable Tamás Kátai. Kátai has been steadily pumping out generally great and wholly unique black/folk/prog metal, with many escapades into the weird, the jazzy and beyond along the way. While I liked 2016s Meta, I lost track of Thy Catafalques impressively fast output afterwards, until the band snagged me hook, line and sinker with 2021's Vadak, I’ve remained a fan but with some reservations since. I enjoyed both Alföld (2023) and XII: A gyönyörű álmok ezután jönneki (2024). However, I have rarely revisited them, and I fear Sárga erdő will befall a similar fate.
This is hardly because it’s a bad or even less than great album. Instead, it’s because— after almost three decades and an impressive 13 albums released—Kátai and his army of support artists have established a very particular niche and sound. There is a tendency of recurring melodies and motifs throughout different albums. Within the confines of a very specific sound, Thy Catafalque varies wildly, and does some truly impressive genre-bending that should not work but usually does. At that point, you might as well pick a particular album out of the band’s catalog and stick with it. For some it might be Sgúrr, Meta, Alföld or any of the others. For me it is—and will probably remain—Vadak.
I enjoy the bouncy folk-infused first half of the album and its surprisingly huge and stomping riffs, but am somewhat let down by the long-form title-track and closer. While they hold great moments, like the magnificent intro of “87 tavasz, 87 ősz”, they don’t justify their length on an album that already totters under the weight of its ambition and self-referential nature. I also miss the nimble, more blackened and sometimes downright venomous outbursts that balanced more meandering or zany passages with a slavering, serrated urgency. Late album highlight "Tömbök" comes closest, and is a welcome flash of fangs and whirling weirdness in between two tracks that frankly overstay their welcome.
For those who prefer a bouncier and less blackened Thy Catalfalque, or those new to their sound, Sárga erdő might be a pretty great place to start. The album is generally digestible, and works in some hard-hitting psychedelic riffs on “Suhamló éji fák” and “Puszta”that remind me of Villagers of Ioannina City, while allowing the veritable army of over 30 neatly credited guest musicians to shine in their respective contributions. And, if you don’t like this one, then go and listen to the title-track off Vadak. Then, go and thank Tamás Kátai and his army of guest musicians for their indomitable efforts to make the world of metal better and weirder in their very specific fashion.