40. Godspeed You! Black Emperor – Asunder, Sweet And Other Distress

40 GY!BE AsunderWhile Godspeed’s latest effort, Asunder, Sweet and Other Distress didn’t have the same level of reunion hype that their previous LP, Allelujah! Don’t Bend! Ascend had, the band didn’t really lose any of their darkness or edge, despite this record’s more subtle and timid first impressions. With the band’s fifth full-length, the Canadian godfathers of post-rock have placed even more emphasis this time around on atmosphere and ambience. There’s as little rock to be found here as possible, while still maintaining the band’s classic, climax-heavy aesthetic. Tracks like “Lambs’ Breath” and “Piss Crowns are Trebled” are absolutely terrifying in their context and are certainly one of the darkest pieces to come out of the band’s discography thus far. You should definitely listen to the aforementioned tracks alone and with a good set of headphones on, but just don’t say that Heavy Blog Is Heavy didn’t warn you first. It may not be as instantly gratifying or as memorable as some of their classic albums, but Asunder still shows how masterful each member of the band is at interlocking all of their parts, how to perfectly navigate colossal dynamic shifts, and managing to say a hell of a lot while actually delivering very little at the same time.

[soundcloud url=”https://api.soundcloud.com/tracks/192622921″ params=”color=ff5500&auto_play=false&hide_related=false&show_comments=true&show_user=true&show_reposts=false” width=”100%” height=”166″ iframe=”true” /]

-Kit Brown

39. Kamasi Washington – The Epic

39 Kamasi Washington EpicIn capping off my extensive praise of The Epic during our inaugural Jazz Club conversation, I claimed that Kamasi Washington’s debut would eventually be regarded as a classic in spiritual jazz, alongside John Coltrane’s A Love Supreme and Pharaoh Sanders’ Karma. And each time I revisited this three hour masterpiece over the course of the year, that assertion only further solidified itself in my mind. One of Nick’s comments in our conversation captured exactly why: The Epic is a capital “J” jazz album. All of the album’s seventeen tracks either reference or emulate the genre’s major movements through a distinctly fresh and inspired approach. Kamasi’s playing is perhaps the greatest asset to this achievement; his mastery of the sax manifests via the unbridled emotion of Sanders, utter fearlessness of Ornette Coleman and the sheer technical prowess of Coltrane, all while sounding distinctly “Kamasi.”

But what ultimately defines every great jazz musician is their band leading ability, something that Kamasi demonstrates in spades with The Epic’s lush compositions. The way in which he leads his fellow brass brats – trombone via Ryan Porter and trumpet via Igmar Thomas – atop Thundercat’s incomparable bass lines and Ronald Bruner, Jr. & Leon Mobley’s eclectic percussion makes it difficult to comprehend that this is Kamasi’s debut album. And while I don’t typically enjoy jazz vocals, The Epic not only includes some excellent solo vocals from Dwight Trible and Patrice Quinn, but also frequents the use of massive spiritual choruses, spreading the grandiosity of the album even further.

Essentially, anyone who claims to be a fan of jazz and doesn’t enjoy The Epic should really assess their preferences. And while they revisit the album and hopefully discover why their opinion’s invalid, I’ll be on the floor weeping to Kamasi’s heart-wrenching phrases on “Askim.”

[soundcloud url=”https://api.soundcloud.com/tracks/211072304″ params=”color=ff5500&auto_play=false&hide_related=false&show_comments=true&show_user=true&show_reposts=false” width=”100%” height=”166″ iframe=”true” /]

-Scott Murphy

38. Caligula’s Horse – Bloom

38 Caligulas Horse BloomFollowing on from their tremendous 2013 release, The Tide, the Thief and River’s End, Caligula’s Horse returned in 2015 with the magnificent Bloom, proving they’re at the top of their game and hungry to build on their past success. The band is starting to gain some serious traction internationally, and it’s easy to see why. They’ve proven to be remarkably versatile, the vibrant, uplifting nature of Bloom a sharp contrast to the dark, brooding masterpiece which preceded it. Yet, despite such a dramatic shift in album aesthetics, the ethereal vocals of Jim Grey, the introspective lyrics and the instantly recognisable guitar tone mark this album as unmistakably Caligula’s Horse. The album is a mixture of straight-ahead tracks such as the emotional “Firelight,” and longer, more progressive pieces such as the title track. “Daughter of the Mountain” takes its listeners on a journey, the infectious guitar licks and uplifting lyrics of “Turntail” dare us not to smile, whilst the rhythmic, djenty breakdown of “Rust” is sure to get headbangers going. Thus Caligula’s Horse offer genuinely accessible music which makes no compromises, a rare gift allowing them to bring meaningful music to a large audience without compromising their integrity. There really is something in Bloom for everyone to enjoy and one thing’s for damn sure, enjoy it we shall.

-Karlo Doroc

37. Tangled Thoughts of Leaving – Yield to Despair

37 TToL Yield to DespairThere are probably only so many times I can write about this band this year without utterly repeating myself, but it’s truly a testament to the immense talent and originality of this Perth-based group that their latest full-length caught on with our staff and really took hold despite few having much familiarity with them prior to this year. Yield to Despair is a landmark record and statement for this experimental post-metal group, one that takes the many sounds and influences the band have touched upon since their formation and utilizes their strength as a unit built on improvisation and interplay to create some of the darkest and most affecting music out there. This is an album that will slowly, but surely, exhaust you emotionally and pull any sadness and agony present within you out into the foreground.

The group’s combination of drone, jazz, doom, and other more conventional post-metal sounds is not only a breath of fresh air musically; they work together brilliantly to form a perfect mixture of darkness and light, offering just enough glimmering hope (often in the form of Ron Pollard’s impeccable keys/piano work) to make the ultimate crushing “despair” always either lurking underneath or out in front all the more devastating. What the band have surrendered in technical brilliance here and in their more recent output they’ve more than made up for in sheer weight and compositional mastery. This is an exceedingly dense collection of music, but one that will still grab you immediately and refuse to let go until the very last note dies out, revealing the despair inside of you all along and somehow still making you want to repeat the process over and over again.

[bandcamp width=100% height=120 album=3040328723 size=large bgcol=ffffff linkcol=0687f5 tracklist=false artwork=small]

-Nick Cusworth

36. Arcane – Known / Learned

36 Arcane Known LearnedStraight up progressive metal is a genre that is often deemed to have peaked. There doesn’t seem to be much left to do with it without bringing in other genres for some sort of inspiration. However, that doesn’t mean it can’t still make beautiful music and conjure up some of the best albums around. Arcane is a very good example of that: with recognizable parts for the guitars, synths, drums and vocals, it doesn’t innovate much on the musical level.

But what it lacks there, it more than makes up for in scope, ambition and execution. It is a masterful conceptual album, creating musical themes that echo with the listener throughout, creating something that is bigger than the sum of its pieces. Drawing on diverse influences from within the progressive metal scene, it seems to blend these discrete elements into something new, a child of the genre that stands on its own and claims its own identity. This double album also has another amazing quality: its long run time never tires. It does this by relying on several musical themes rather than one, interchanging them to create interest and engagement. The fact that the amazing Jim Grey does their vocals doesn’t hurt either.

[bandcamp width=100% height=120 album=4170540305 size=large bgcol=ffffff linkcol=0687f5 tracklist=false artwork=small]

-Eden Kupermintz

35. Ghost – Meliora

35 Ghost MelioraUpon hearing mention of Ghost, the first image my mind conjures is that of Papa Emeritus standing on stage in full regalia, face painted, as smoke swirls ominously around him, all but obscuring his masked bandmates. Yet, despite the undeniable importance of the band’s occult imagery, the fact remains that it is the band’s music which allows them to remain relevant. Their brand of doom-infused 70’s rock has made waves since their debut in 2010, and Meliora sees them deliver arguably their best record yet. The songwriting is exemplary, the album brimming with memorable hooks and infectious choruses which stay in your head for weeks at a time. The inherent darkness of the lyrics bewitchingly contrast with the poppy delivery of the vocals, the result beguilingly sinister. The vocals are an acquired taste, but they’re worth the effort as they provide the album with its emotive drive and complement the synths and piano superbly. The rhythm section is understated throughout, the bass and drums serving the song and allowing the listener to focus more intensely upon this record’s main attraction, its riffs. The riffs on tracks such as “Absolution” and “Cirice” are absolutely monstrous, and it’s no surprise to see that the latter has received a thoroughly deserved grammy nomination. Sinister yet accessible, heavy yet poppy, Ghost are striking a delicate balance between opposing forces, and the resulting energy is an absolute joy to behold.

-Karlo Doroc

34. Caspian – Dust and Disquiet

34 Caspian Dust and DisquietWatching a band grow throughout their career is always amazing to see. In 2005, Caspian released their debut EP, You Are The Conductor, and here they are 10 years later, releasing their 4th studio album Dust and Disquiet. With this album, they decided to go in a more experimental route yet still keeping their heavy yet emotional sound, and it is arguably their best album to date. In a sea of instrumental post-rock bands, this album proves that Caspian are a master of their craft at the top of the genre. Dust and Disquiet is an album of growth and evolution, as they continue to expand their sound to different lengths, whether it’s adding more layers or new sounds. From their last album, Waking Season, to where they are now, they really pushed themselves as a band and used sounds new and old to great emotional effect. Tracks like “Ríoseco” and “Arcs of Command” show how heavy they can get, yet still smack you in the face with some emotion whether you were ready for it or not. Then you have “Darkfield,” where they proudly display their more experimental side.

The gorgeous album cover is an homage to Caspian’s late bassist, Chris Fredrich, who passed away in 2013. Featuring 6 black feathers and 1 white feather in a circle, the art and music contained within represent the greatest tribute the band could provide. Friedrich will always be a part of the band in one way or another, and Dust and Disquiet is a testament to the longevity and heartfelt musical emotion coursing through the band’s work.

[bandcamp width=100% height=120 album=153858327 size=large bgcol=ffffff linkcol=0687f5 tracklist=false artwork=small]

-Mark Valentino

33. Enslaved – In Times

33 Enslaved-In-TimesSeeing a band thirteen albums into their career put out such heartfelt and honest-feeling music is a sight to behold. Enslaved have been making progressive black metal in this vein for over a decade now, and they show no signs of slowing down or burning out. The soothing clean vocals intermixed with the screaming, the meditative riffing juxtaposed with tense black metal playing, Enslaved are a band of dualities, and they handle both ends of the spectrum and everything in between very well. The key here is authenticity – the band retreated to a cabin in the woods for the process of the album, like they often do for their releases. And despite having nearly-10-minute-long progressive pieces, the band remain to be very accessible by packing their sound in multiple layers that one can unfold for more and more joy.

-Noyan Tokgozoglu

32. The Dear Hunter – Act IV: Rebirth In Reprise

32 TDH Act IVOne of the biggest challenges for an artist/band with either a well-established sound or a musical universe they’ve constructed is holding true to that sound or universe while still being able to subvert expectations of what that sound should be exactly. Few have been able to walk this tightrope as brilliantly as Casey Crescenzo and prog-rock act The Dear Hunter. If you listen to Acts I-III of their overarching concept album series focused around the titular character of The Dear Hunter, there is a very easily definable sound or set of sounds present throughout. There are themes, callbacks, and certain musical parameters within each installment that subtly builds off of what the previous installment accomplished. So perhaps the greatest surprise of Act IV was how it not only held true to the legacy of those previous albums but absolutely redefined, recontextualized, and refreshed the entire series in ways no one could have predicted.

Crescenzo made the best use of the six-year span in between Acts III & IV and used what he gained in compositional and songwriting experience to assemble 74 minutes of gripping and immensely entertaining music. The music is more subtle, more “mature,” if you will, but it does not sacrifice any of the more grandiose and fun aspects that made the previous installments so deliriously enjoyable to spin over and over again. Rather, he often doubled down on creating instantly memorable melodies and made frequent use of musical and lyrical callbacks without it ever feeling forced or maudlin. It’s certainly no surprise to anyone who has followed my writings on the band in the past year that this was my personal AOTY, but it’s also immensely satisfying to see it grab the attention of so many others, including those on staff here. Act IV is in every way a success because of how it met and exceeded pretty much every expectation of it. It certainly manages to raise the bar even higher for Acts V and VI (whenever they come), but if there’s one thing Crescenzo and The Dear Hunter have taught their fans in the past decade, it’s to expect the unexpected, and to fall in love with their music time and time again.

-Nick Cusworth

31. Teramaze – Her Halo

31 Teramaze Her Halo“The path to being this good is usually a long one.” These were the words an editor of the blog used to describe Teramaze’s amazing 2015 release and fifth full-length, Her Halo. Having formed in 1995, Teramaze was an older band with a few solid but ultimately average albums under their belt. Something seems to have finally clicked with the group, because their latest offering has propelled them to the forefront of the power-prog genre and given listeners of catchy, heavy music a new benchmark with which to compare other releases.

Nearly everything about Her Halo is grandiose, from the beefy, thundering riffs to the glossy modern production that truly brings out the best of the compositions. Vocalist Nathan Peachey, new to the band as of 2014, deftly guides listeners through a labyrinth of juddering riffs with his angelic voice, and his instantly accessible melodies are catchy enough to hook listeners on their first play. That said, there’s enough meat to the instrumentation and enough subtleties hiding amongst the album’s more obvious facets to warrant repeat listens. With everything from single-ready anthems to 10+ minute prog adventures, Her Halo is an exhilarating triumph of progressive metal.

-Andrew Westlake

65 Responses

  1. BarakalypseNow

    This is the article I wait all year for. And YOOOOO!! I really love the selections of albums that I have been rocking (especially #1!), but it’s clear that there are so many great ones I haven’t heard! The mountain of good music that metalheads have to bear is unbelievable, but in the end totally worth it. I think I’m only doing a top 10 this year, just because I didn’t do as much listening as prior years.

    10. Voices – London
    9. Thy Art Is Murder – Holy War
    8. Cattle Decapitation – The Anthropocene Extinction
    7. Rivers of Nihil – Monarchy
    6. Tempel – The Moon Lit Our Path
    5. Elder – Lore
    4. Native Construct – Quiet World
    3. Deafheaven – New Bermuda
    2. Intronaut – The Direction of Last Things
    1. Dreadnought – Bridging Realms

    EDIT: Changed #10 to Voices…forgot how much I liked that album at the start of the year.

  2. BlackTaxi2d

    nice, interesting to see a few albums here that are tops on many people’s charts chilling between 40 and 50

    • Karlo Doroc

      i know right, just goes to show how good of a year 2015 was. there were even some records which individuals had in their top 10, which didn’t make our aggregate top 50! look out for our outliers post later in the week, which will cover some of the best albums which sadly didn’t make it onto this list

      • brutal_sushi

        Its fighting for my number one spot. Its slowly becoming the album I listen to the most. The backstory about what the album is about and all the research and everything Anton put into is fascinating, and haunting at the same time.

      • Karlo Doroc

        haunting indeed, the atmosphere they created is simply incredible. i did some basic research into the concept and it sounded amazing, i’ll need to dig deeper into exactly what happened

  3. Washington Skidrow

    It’s so cool to see stuff like The Epic and To Pimp a Butterfly sitting on a mostly metal list. Always appreciate how open minded you guys are about music.

  4. Eden

    Hey guys,

    Thanks for your comments. Just so you know, large portions of the site are down right now. So, if this post disappears, please know that that’s why. We’ll probably re-post it tomorrow, to get it rolling properly.

    Thanks for commenting and for understanding! We really appreciate it.

  5. Scarymother

    There’s only one album that I really felt should be there that wasn’t and that’s Chaos Divine’s Colliding Skies.

    Aside from that, good list.

    Also – thanks for the year. I’ve picked up a pile of CDs directly as a result of reading about them on this site and heard a bunch of bands I doubt I would have come across otherwise. Keep up the good work.

    • Josh

      Chaos Divine, VOLA, and (I haven’t seen it on here yet) EIDOLA belongs right up near the top of this damn list.

      • Scarymother

        It appears VOLA missed out (I was also very pleased with Inmazes). I was glad to see Degenetaterra at about #17 – that album is excellent (my #2 for the year).

      • Eden

        Eidola is an interesting album. It’s definitely great but there’s just so much going on. I feel like the scattering in the overall structure of it (I’ve only listened to it from start to finish several times, although I spin solitary tracks all the time for example) prevents it from being a true list topper.

        If they build on this base with the next release and get something a bit more solidified out there, they can make a true masterpiece.

      • Scarymother

        I love the album, but had no issues with where it was in the list. As the previous guy said, I was happy to see it on the list.

      • el chalupacabra

        Eidola was my #1 of the year, but I have to agree with what Eden said. Given how disorganized it can be at times, and how much of a monolithic listen it is, I’m just happy it’s on here at all.

    • Eden

      I agree with VOLA, see my comment above. Chaos Divine is a good album but it didn’t really bear repeated listens for me. It slowly lost its charm and its edge for me. While it’s a solid album, it’s not…”timeless” enough to make this list, imo.

      Thanks for reading!

      • Scarymother

        Well, it’s all a matter of taste – and that’s both the beauty of music and the trouble with discussing “best of” lists. It’s all subjective – what we’re looking for, what we like etc.

        Clearly plenty of people agree with you on the CD album because I haven’t seen it on too many Top 10 lists, whereas for me, it’s an CD I keep coming back to and the one I’ve probably listened to more than any other this year.

        Anyway, I feel like you blokes are judging these things from the right angle, so I can’t argue with the list.

        By the bye, I picked up the Intronaut disc after giving it a listen due to it appearing at #1.

    • Karlo Doroc

      great to see some love for Chaos Divine! i had it in my top 40 or so if i remember correctly, and it certainly wouldn’t be undeserving a spot on this list. i do see what eden is saying though in that this was just such an amazing year for music, and in my opinion it doesn’t hold up as well on repeat listens compared with some of the other albums. still, nobody can deny that it’s a great record :)

  6. KingdomOfApple

    Solid list, and I know it’s all opinion and whatnot, but where to everloving HECK is VOLA’s Inmazes? I’m actually surprised that, not only did it not make it on the least, but that it wasn’t number one, or in the top ten at the very least. Anyway, still a great list, and I’m sure it’ll be mentioned in one of the other top albums list.

    • Nayon

      Since this is an aggregate list, it means that if some people who write for us didn’t like it as much as others then it didn’t have a huge chance. My AOTY is sitting at 49!

      • KingdomOfApple

        I completely understand that, it was just really surprising to not see it there, haha. That album’s been making waves through the prog metal scene from what I’ve seen. Certainly not as much as others, but it’s still there.

    • Eden

      I know! It’s such a great album and I voted for it really high on my own lists, but it just didn’t make it. Oh well, it still fucking rips.

      Thanks for reading!

      • KingdomOfApple

        No worries! Thanks for sharing so much great music! No Top x albums list is going to be agreed by everyone!

  7. Óśćáŕ

    Probably, you don’t agree with me, but i see Intronaut a a slower-paced Son of Aurelius, with a clearly different style.

  8. algekevin

    Really upset to not see Vehemence’s new album up there, that album is amazing. :( Overall great list though, found a lot of new stuff on here! I also second Kauan – Sorni Nai, but definitely see it not being something for most people though the story behind it is great too!

    • Karlo Doroc

      Sorni Nai really came out of nowehere for me, there was a period where I couldn’t listen to anything else – it may have even cracked my personal top 20 if i remember correctly

  9. guitar_shredda*

    Don’t want to sound funny but I REALLY enjoyed Northlane’s album from this year, some catchy progressive Metalcore, thought it was way better than what August Burns Red put out. Also think Rosetta and Maserati could have easily made the list

    • Eclecticore

      Maserati totally made my list, which isn’t surprising given that I reviewed it and loved it. That was probably gonna be an uphill battle with this group though haha. Just happy to see a lot of the other post-rock I loved made it on here.


  10. rafa

    Am I the only one that thought Good Yiger just sounded like a variant of old Closure in Moscow? I didn’t feel like they were covering any new territory at all

    • Eclecticore

      It being released so late probably didn’t help, but I also don’t think it caught on a ton with the staff as a whole beyond a couple of people who are really into him. It’s been near the top of so many other lists though that I was surprised to see that it didn’t crack ours.


  11. MelbCro

    1. Swallow the Sun – Songs of the North I,II & III
    2. Shape of Despair – Monotony Fields
    3. Arcane – Known/Learned
    4. Earthside – A Dream in Static
    5. Between the Buried and Me – Coma Ecliptic
    6. Steven Wilson – Hand. Cannot. Erase.
    7. Leprous – The Congregation
    8. Native Construct – Quiet World
    9. Agent Fresco – Destrier
    10. Riverside – Love, Fear And The Time Machine
    11. My Dying Bride – Feel the Misery
    12. Enslaved – In Times
    13. Transience – Temple
    14. Ahab – The Boats Of The Glen Carrig
    15. Caligula’s Horse – Bloom
    16. The Slow Death – Ark
    17. Skepticism – Ordeal
    18. Monolithe – Epsilon Aurigae
    19. Alkaloid – The Malkuth Grimoire
    20. Bell Witch – Four Phantoms

  12. Midgetwithalimp

    Awesome list, but I’m sad to see that the new Black Breath record is missing, saw them twice live this year and the material they played from Slaves Beyond Death was insane

  13. Gwynblade

    Oh wow, this is probably the nicest comments section I have seen in years especially when it comes to lists like this.

  14. HugoBoss_Enema

    Alkaloid is my #1. Thanks for making this list, found a couple really cool band thanks to it.
    Gracias. Happy Holidays
    I would’ve added Jesse Cook, Purity Ring, Sumac, and Chelsea Wolfe.

  15. lrn2swim

    The 2 best albums of the year IMO didn’t even make your top 50!

    1a. Dødheimsgard – A Umbra Omega
    1b. Beardfish – +4626-COMFORTZONE (one of the greatest 70’s prog rock albums ever happened to be made in 2015)

    Love your guys’ list though, so much awesome tunage!!

  16. 1 Screaming Dizbuster

    A couple of my favorite releases from 2015 which totally flew under the Metal Press radar were False Lights by Finland’s Pressure Points, a progressive/death metal masterpiece. Their long awaited release after 2010’s promising debut Remorses to Remember. The contrast of death and clean passages may not be original but the level of songwriting, musicianship, and production truly stand out. They have a unique sound and it is glorious.

    The other is the newest release from the reformed Transport League – Napalm Bats and Suicide Dogs. Tony Jelencovich sings/screams/howls his ass off and his backing band lays down some serious grooves. Take Clutch and turn it up a few notches and that’s where this band resides.

    • karlo

      i can’t help but get excited whenever i hear the words progressive, death, metal and masterpiece all in the same sentence. I’ll have to check it out!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.